J.J. McCarthy Debut sparks Vikings’ 27-24 MNF rally over Bears
File this under first impressions that hit like a hammer. The J.J. McCarthy debut went from jittery to historic in one quarter, as the Minnesota Vikings erased an 11-point deficit at Soldier Field and beat the Chicago Bears 27-24 on Monday Night Football with 21 unanswered points in the fourth.
The rookie quarterback, playing his first competitive game since the 2024 college championship and first in the NFL after a long rehab from a torn meniscus, authored a finish that will live in franchise lore. He became the first quarterback ever to account for three fourth-quarter touchdowns in his debut. He also joined Steve Young as the only QBs in the past 45 years to win their first NFL start after trailing by double digits in the fourth.
That all came after a messy first half and a third quarter that looked like a lesson in patience. McCarthy managed just 48 passing yards before halftime and handed Chicago a gift in the third: a 74-yard pick-six by corner Nahshon Wright that stretched the Bears’ lead to 17-6. On the road. In the division. Under the lights. Most rookies would fold. He didn’t.
How the game flipped
Chicago opened like a team with a fresh voice and a sharp plan. In his first game as head coach, Ben Johnson leaned into familiar strengths from his Detroit days: get the quarterback comfortable, win early downs, control rhythm. Second-year passer Caleb Williams started 10-for-10, hit short throws in stride, and punched in his first rushing touchdown. He later added a scoring throw, and by the time Wright raced the interception back, the Bears looked in command.
But the signs of friction were already there. Chicago committed four false starts in the first half alone. The cadence misfires that haunted training camp showed up in prime time. The Bears wound up drawing 11 flags for 122 yards, and two late defensive pass interference penalties tilted the field at the worst moments.
Minnesota survived the bumpy opening because its defense quietly kept the game within reach. After Chicago went up 17-6, the Vikings’ front tightened up against the run, tackled better in space, and forced shorter drives. Field position improved. The sideline calmed. McCarthy’s coaches trimmed the call sheet, mixed formations, and asked him to operate quicker. You could see the plan switch from “prove you can do everything” to “do three things really well, right now.”
The pivot came with tempo and trust. McCarthy started layering rhythm throws instead of hunting big shots. He moved the pocket, got the ball out on time, and used Justin Jefferson as his anchor. Jefferson’s 13-yard touchdown in the fourth was classic star-on-the-spot: tight split, decisive cut, ball on the upfield shoulder. Minnesota then cut the deficit to a field goal, and the Bears’ offense—so smooth early—lost its grip.
Next came the drive that told you the rookie had settled in. Facing a defense bracing to protect the boundary, McCarthy froze the second level with backfield action and ripped a 27-yard touchdown to Aaron Jones. It wasn’t a bailout heave; it was an “I know where this is going before the snap” throw. The Vikings took the lead, and Chicago felt the ground tilt.
His final score was the dagger. With the Bears spread wide to stop the perimeter, McCarthy kept the ball on a designed run and sliced 14 yards to the pylon. Three touchdowns in one quarter—two through the air and one on the ground—sealed a comeback that flipped the noise in the building.
Stat lines rarely tell the whole story, but Monday’s did. McCarthy finished 13-of-20 for 143 yards, and he was 6-of-8 for 87 yards in the fourth quarter alone. Add the two touchdown throws and the rushing score, and you see a rookie who processed, adjusted, and delivered when the game demanded it. The 609-day layoff? Forgotten by the time the clock bled out.
Chicago did rally late, punching in a touchdown with 2:02 left to slice the margin to three. But it came after Minnesota had already put the game in a chokehold. The Vikings bled the rest of the clock and walked off without giving the Bears another real shot.
What it says about both teams
For Minnesota, this was more than a Week 1 win. The franchise made a bet in the offseason, moving on from veteran stopgaps Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones and declining to chase Aaron Rodgers in free agency. That decision put a spotlight on development, patience, and the upside of a young quarterback with big-stage experience. Monday showed why the Vikings were willing to live with growing pains. They got the growth and the payoff in one night.
The schematic tweaks late were smart and simple. Minnesota protected with help when it needed to, sprinkled in play-action and quick game, and gave McCarthy easy early answers. The staff leaned into concepts he executed in college—movement throws, defined reads, run-pass tags—until everything slowed down. When it did, his ball placement sharpened, and he hit receivers in stride instead of throwing to spots and hoping. That’s how you build confidence without babying a quarterback.
It helped that the stars showed up. Jefferson created separation and bailouts. Jones, a savvy veteran back, gave McCarthy a reliable outlet and a mismatch option on linebackers. The Vikings’ defense matched the moment, too, limiting Chicago to just three points between the middle of the third quarter and the final two minutes. That calm counterpunch kept the game from drifting out of reach while the offense found its footing.
Chicago, meanwhile, has a foundation to build on, but the homework is plain. Williams looked controlled and accurate early, leveraging Johnson’s scripted series and clean pocket mechanics. His first 10 completions weren’t empty calories; they kept everything on schedule and spread the ball around. The issue wasn’t talent. It was discipline. Eleven penalties for 122 yards is how you waste a strong plan, especially when two of them are defensive pass interference calls that flip the field and lead directly to points.
The false starts are more than noise. They’re drive-killers that turn second-and-manageable into second-and-long and put pressure on protections. The Bears also grew conservative with a lead, leaning on short throws that Minnesota began to sit on. As the Vikings closed the cushion, Chicago’s answers shrank. The offense will need a counter when defenses squeeze the underneath windows and dare them to win outside the numbers.
Johnson’s debut also offered a look at game management under stress. Early, the tempo and sequencing popped. Later, the Bears looked slow getting in and out of plays, and they paid for it with pre-snap mistakes. That’s fixable—and it has to be—because the North won’t forgive sloppiness. The tape will show opportunities left on the field and a defense that couldn’t get off it when Minnesota leaned on high-percentage concepts.
For Williams, there’s enough on film to feel encouraged. He protected the ball, took what was there, and handled the moment. The next step is turning that 10-for-10 script into sustained drives after the defense adjusts. He won’t face a fourth quarter like this every week, but he’ll see plenty of late-game pressure. How quickly Chicago cleans up the cadence, communication, and secondary technique will dictate whether the Bears’ potential becomes real.
It’s hard to overstate how heavy this stage was for McCarthy. Road opener. Divisional opponent. Monday night spotlight. First game action since college. He didn’t win with a stat avalanche. He won with timing, urgency, and composure. The late sequence—touchdown to Jefferson, touchdown to Jones, quarterback keeper to finish it—showed processing and poise, not just arm talent.
Zoom out, and the history adds weight. Three fourth-quarter touchdowns in an NFL debut is unprecedented. Doing it while erasing a double-digit deficit—something only Steve Young had done in the last 45 years—gives it a place in the record book and in the Vikings’ memory. Fans will circle this one for a while. Teams will circle his name on scouting reports right now.
There’s a long season ahead, and no rookie is a finished product after one night. Defenses will adjust, take away his comfort throws, and test his patience. The Vikings will ask him to handle more. But the baseline—the ability to steady himself when a game goes sideways, to command a huddle under stress, and to finish drives—showed up under the harshest light. Coaches love that because it’s the hardest thing to teach.
As for Chicago, the path forward is obvious: cut the penalties in half, win the line of scrimmage with cadence and communication, and trust the young quarterback to make throws on schedule when the run game stalls. Johnson’s reputation as a creative mind is intact; now it’s about operational excellence. Clean up the noise, and the Bears have enough to bother people. Leave it alone, and even a strong start can slip away, just like it did here.
Week 1s are rarely elegant. This one had all the rough edges—missed throws, flags, a pick-six—and then it had a finish built on clarity. The Vikings found it first. Their rookie found it fastest.
Related Post
Type your Comment
Your E-mail Address is secured. Required Fields are marked (*)